Will this mascara reign as the winner? We will see! So far this is the best mascara I have ever used! The brush grabs every lash. It separated lashes beautifully so they don't all clump together. The formula seems dry, but it makes it very build-able without looking spidery. You can put on as little or as much as you would like. A little looks very natural. A lot seriously makes your lashes look fake. My husband refused to believe I wasn't wearing false lashes. Each time he looked at me he said "that mascara stuff is amazing." It didn't flake off or get under my eyes at all and I used it on my lower lashes. It stayed put.
Verdict: False lash appeal! This mascara leaves lashes looking long and thick, not spidery. It does not flake off. I will certainly buy this one! I love it!